WoTC is way more immersive than BG3. Despite it's good gameplay and graphics, BG3 always throw at our heads that it's a video game.
Does everyone agree with this assessment?
Yes, since day 1. I think it was one of greatest strengths of the originals back in the day. But Larian is completely out of touch with the originals, have you seen them mentioning BG1/2 any time? I was surprised when Swen mentioned immersion on Patch 5, until then I never imagined he knew what the word meant.
Regarding PF WOTR, it looks like a really nice game, but the setting doesn't appeal to me. That giant cockroach demon dropping from the sky and killing a dragon was too much for me.