Originally Posted by Abits
Please expand on how it is worse. What is the BG3 equivalent of Arkanis Gath for example? Why didn't the tieflings in BG3 throw my evil character a party after she murdered them, the way the elves in BG2 do after you kill them in Suldanesslar?
I'm not sure I want to get into this game since we're digressing, but if you are talking about reactivity, I think even though it's 20 years old, bg2 is still better. It is more limited, but the story is more cohesive for it.[/quote]
That's would be a big debate whenver more is objectively better. Arguably the best RPG even made would be Witcher2 as it has two seperate chapters, with unique NPCs and questlines, and yet I would argue this was the biggest mistep the series has taken, and the weakest entry because of it's ambitious reactivity.

To me personally, amount of reactivity is irrelevant if I am not engaged in the moment of making the decision or don't care about outcomes. That is something I will not be ever able to argue for objectively.