Ethel's got a lotion for that!
hehe not really though

[Linked Image from i.ibb.co]

I mean I assume we're talking about the dumbass facial expression used whenever the MC is supposed to be surprised or aghast right? Like when we turn that poor mysterious woman into a mind flayer 'at the flip of the switch.' And then we get that nice cutaway to show us just how hot our wifi hotspot is in that moment? hehe. I've heard it brought up elsewhere, but not described in such cutting meme terms. I kinda agree though, it's a bit overused and not everyone has the eyebrow control like Ash to make it work to their advantage lol