Larian Studios Forums Baldur's Gate III Baldur's Gate III - Suggestions & Feedback The BG3 Story

So here's another example of story inconsistencies. I'm just pointing out what I find as I'm going through stuff.

You enter the storeroom in the tiefling camp. There's Pandirna. She's on the floor with her legs sprawled out. She says, "It was inventory today, but my nerves are shot after the attack."

What attack is she referring to? She certainly wasn't at the grove gate just now helping to fight off the goblins and save Aradin. I can only assume she's referring to the gnoll attack that is brought up multiple times by the tieflings in the grove; you know, the one that killed tieflings like Lahala.

But if that attack was weeks ago, or even longer, why are Pandirna's nerves STILL shot? Certainly, it must have at least been almost a week prior to the MC and the party coming to the grove. After all, as mentioned previously, Halsin and Aradin have been gone for some time. They were expected back a long time before Aradin finally returned.

So is Pandirna in shock from the goblin attack that we were able to wipe out without much of an issue? I mean, even if my party didn't kill those goblins, it really doesn't seem like the goblins were going to win that fight. Aradin might have died, but I really don't think we "saved the grove". If we truly saved the grove from that small of a goblin band, then MAN, them tieflings and druids are totally weak and incapable of fighting. Honestly, the druids must be nothing but total initiates, all of them, because any decent gathering of druids should have been able to wipe out that goblin party no problem. And Zevlor is obviously also a very weak tiefling HELLRIDER!

And, again, Pandirna isn't even at the wall when the fight occurs, so what she SO freaked out about that her nerves are super shot?

What makes sense is that she is referring to the gnoll encounter, since most tieflings refer to the gnoll encounter as a very terrible experience. Lahala was torn to shreds by gnolls, and it deeply affected Alfira.

So what is the explanation here? Is Pandirna referring to the gnoll attack or the goblin raid on the grove gate? I originally assumed the goblin raid, but upon further thought I said to myself, "That can't be right. Makes no sense."