Originally Posted by Nightshade3226
Originally Posted by Wormerine
Originally Posted by Firesong
I'm so happy that this changed - weighted dice + abilities to increase the dice roll value gave us the agency we desired.
I am still not sure how I feel about the dices, as at this point it is pretty much impossible to loose a dice roll - in unlikely case you won't boost through the required AC with the use of modifiers, there are plenty of rerolls available. As such skill check system is meaningless and could as well not exist, unless some players intentionally fail checks to see what happens. Also work put into "failstates" might as well be wasted if it is so difficult to fail (and most of us won't want to fail intentionally - because it never feels as good as winning).

I assume skill check values shall be raised up, as to avoid having 100% passability. And if that happens, and while it is far better to be able to apply boosts in visible and impactful way, will it feel much different?

As it is I still think flat skill checks (like in New Vegas) make most sense in cRPGs as:
1) they get rid of RNG bullcrap
2) enforce different path availability during different playthroughs.

What? I spent 20 minutes reloading the game trying to not fail the skill check against the Mind Flayer that auto-kills you if you fail, and another 20 trying to not fail the 2-3 checks against the tadpole from the dead dwarf that lets it get away the last time I played.

How the hell are you saying it's not possible to fail them?
I think most of us just avoid that flayer check by shooting it with bow. The dwarf tadpole one is the only hard check that is forced on you in the game at the moment imo, if you go charisma. So long as you use your pop-up abilities and gather Inspiration Points. Compare that to the early patches where even spec'd for charisma you were going to fail a fair few of you checks since there was no choice to use abilities in the dice-roller and inspiration points were more scarce.

Last edited by alice_ashpool; 04/10/21 09:59 AM.