I still say: BG3 is best, then Solasta, then Pathfinder.
To each their own. We all have our personal preferences. For me (and judging BG3 by what I've seen of the game without having yet played it myself): P:WotR > Black Geyser > BG3 > Solasta (with BG3 edging out Solasta only because it is set in the Forgotten Realms)
