It should definitely be different if you eat 1 food or 39 but I really don't like your choices suggestion to be honnest.
Resting is resting. It would not make sense at all to choose what to recover and to have one more (or less) short rest "point".
I think it should more be "something like" :
40/40: fully recover as usual
30-39/40: 3/4 HP + full spellslot + full feature recovery
20-29/40: 1/2 HP + 1/2 spellslot + full feature recovery
10-19/40: 1/4 HP + 1/2 spellslot + no feature recovery
Last edited by Maximuuus; 16/10/21 06:05 AM.