I did, actually:
Actually many folk here have been giving feedback for along time about various Larian homebrew, positive and negative, and offering harsh feedback where it upsets game balance - shove, you might be aware, is a particularly contentious one, in fact.
We're talking about critical successes and failures, however: that is the
Topic of this thread.
So, while many people have many objections to many of Larian's other homebrew decisions, they are all eagerly discussed in other threads directly related to them. This one is about critical successes and failures.
They have been in older editions. They are not in 5e, except for attack rolls and death saves. That is the simple fact. You can contend that they *should* be a part of 5e, and a part of Larian's games - that's a fine opinion to have and you're welcome to voice it and argue for it, and explain why you feel it should be so and continue to be so, absolutely! (Please do, in fact - I'd appreciate hearing more from someone who genuinely enjoys that mechanic and would like to know more about why.)
However, don't claim that it *is* a part of the 5e rule set, optional or otherwise, because it is not.
