Wrath of the Righteous is probably my Game of the Year (unless I come across something that completely blows my expectation in the next 2 months), but I can agree that the overall writing is serviceable at best. I find myself noticing a lot more flaws/gaps in the writing with my second playthrough - to the point that my 2nd playthrough is slowing to a crawl because now that I roughly know what happens next, the narrative really isn't hooking me in on its own.
I still think there are moments where Owlcat really nails it, but when you measure assess it as a full body of work against the full play time (which is LONG), I wish a lot more things were better fleshed out and paced.
