BG3 should use a combination toggle & pop-up system.
Everyone is happy.
Actually only the players who want an exact conversion from tabletop would be happy. The rest would still be stuck with a bad system with uncontrollable reactions unless they want to deal with a million prompts.
That's why bigger changes are needed.
What would you suggest then? In your previous post you argue for a mix of automated and pop-up reactions, right? With the addition of some reactions turned into bonus actions or free actions (which are essentially toggles except some cost your bonus action, and possibly they only last for one use).
I'm a bit confused, as our suggestions seem pretty similar... Is the difference between your and my suggestion: you think certain reactions should always be automated, others should always be free/bonus actions (~toggles), and some select others are always pop-ups? Whereas I think all reactions should be able to be switched between a pop-up and a toggle?
Or do you have another suggestion on how to better implement reactions? Honest question; I'm always happy to hear and consider proposed suggestions.
