Yes we need real reactions, but my big fear is that Larian will take a few "mimimi I don't want a pop-up"s over the well-founded reasonings why we need to have reactions on a case to case basis. There is simply no way around them, if you don't want to absolutely gut many class features.
My bet at the moment is that the engine just cannot do it the right way right now. My fear stems from Larian hiding behind some people who just want a good looking action game, but not a DnD game.
Do what Solasta did and give the option to those people who love the random toggle so much.
