Is it just around Selune? I'm trying to remember. You can get her to admit worshipping Shar in the Owlbear cave, but the magic hand thing looks like it only occurs around remnants of the Dark Justiciar attacks. Can anyone confirm that?

I think the triggers for her hand are: the school book, the justiciar helmet, the broken statue near the windmill. Triggers for her faith are all those, but also, the shrine in the owlbear cave and maybe entering the temple of selune? I've been clearing this speech challenge so early my last two playthroughs that I'm not sure if you can trigger it there

Last edited by Sozz; 13/11/21 06:47 AM.