Most people playing the game (the definition of majority) enjoy it. The people enjoying the game are buying the game. Their feedback matters also. They are not irrelevant.
Again. The game feels like a Baldur's Gate game. I've played the other BG games. I've played all the Forgotten Realms games. I've played through multiple DnD games that took place in other settings, including Greyhawk and Darksun. I have a long history of playing in these games.
And this feels like a Baldur's Gate game.
I'd really like to know what makes you feel a Baldur's Gate game when playing BG3.
And because you're probably going to answer "city", "DnD" (Magic missile, D20, AC) and "FR" (Sword coast, underdark, mindflayer)... Can you explain why most people that enjoy those games think that Pillard or Eternity, Pathfinder, Tyranny, Solasta, DA:O (...) feels like BG games and/or are "spiritual successors" ?