Originally Posted by Blackheifer
I'd also like to point out that I have observed that Bg3 - in many ways - falls into the classic experience according to the criteria I outlined.
Sometimes two people can agree on what they think is important in a game, and yet disagree on whether and to what extent that thing exists in a particular game. Take immersion for example. You and I both agree it is a critical element of a good cRPG. And you believe BG3 has planty of immersion. But I disagree, and find BG3 lacking in sufficient immersion for me. We both would agree the quality of writing is very important. You think BG3's writing is strong/excellent. I consider the writing to be abysmal. Even your claim here that BG3 fits the list you wrote up I would dispute in several areas.