Generally in stories, societies like this are described as dystopian, counterproductive and horrible to live in.

Imperium of Man is one such example. GW did not start rewriting the Imperium but rather point out its supposed to be a parody and things taken too far. Its not a manifesto of how things should be and I think thats what most of the knuckleheads misunderstand.
Just as the OP completely misunderstands what the point of all these depictions is. I blame it on lack of education and critical thinking skills when something is observed as a surface level literal translation rather than analyzing the concept in the entire context.

Before this used to be a unique problem with the religious rightwing but now we have... people like OP who probably mean well but end up ruining everything.