Given that this has been discussed dozens of times already, I don't see the usefulness of "resetting the conversation" and starting a new thread about the same topic.
This fundamentally ignores every point made before and implicitly forces people to repeat themselves over and over OR give up on the discussion.
That's not to say that I don't share the sentiment that the current implementation of shove sucks in more ways than one.
My thought... "The squeaky wheel gets the kick."
I HATE shove almost, if not more than, Height/Backstab Advantage. I am insta-killed more times by shove than anything else.
So, maybe if they fix it, people could stop talking about it.
Just like Day/Night, Party of 6, and everything else I want.