Well, since you do ignore shove ...
I cant quite form a counter argument, while expressing my opinion ... since we seem to be in agreement.
Of course i can try to think someting for you, but what would be the point?
Sure it can benefit from improvements ...
I believe that making it full action would be great improvement ... even tho i cant help the feeling that people would be still complaining that "now there is no reason to do regular attack when i can shove anyone off the cliff to instant death" ... so ... im not quite ure if that improvement would be sufficient. :-/
But those are people who have problem with existence itself for those options, and that is something you can either submit ... or even better, ignore as a developer.
Bcs once you start submiting to please everyone, you can pre-order a room in a madhouse right away.
