It does seem to be more than just us, too. The Steam discussions around Shove have been very similar. There was one thread I could find on Reddit that liked the comic nature of shove, but the other threads also mention it is OP and offered similar points on how to balance it out (and more DnD 5e) as have been discussed here (even by those who enjoy the comedic aspect). I don't frequent those boards enough to know anything remotely exhaustive of the discussions, but there does seem to be a large consensus of the problem.
Joe
