Lifting heavy rocks already has a hard strength requirement in BG3. So everyone who are saying "8 strength isn't weak" or "everything needs to be possible for everyone", do you think these should also be a d20 roll?
If you don't think 8 strength is weak (average commoner who doesn't train has 10-11), do you also think 8 wisdom isn't foolish and 8 dex isn't clumsy? You can have no negative effects from negative modifiers? What's the point of having a weak character if they can still perform feats of brute strength successfully with merely 20% less chance than the strongest character?
I'm firmly of the opinion that a d20 strength check doesn't make a big enough difference between puny and strong characters.
