Personally I think it's... I don't want to say "wrong" as it's not exactly the right meaning, but as a player I think it's flawed to treat any D&D-based video game as a replacement of D&D, because it just can't be the same.
I haven't seen these mythical complaints about BG3 not being "the same as tabletop." I don't care about that, and the videogamers on this forum have not stated that. I want the videogame to include all the things everyone knows it could easily include. There have been videogames for 25 years that include far more of the PHB than this one does. There is no good reason why this game could not also have similar levels of mechanics and rules.
