Originally Posted by machinus
Originally Posted by The Composer
Basically, you agree with what I said. Because I didn't disagree.

I can't tell what your opinion is from your post, then. I feel unhappy with the "new" ruleset contained in the current state of BG3, and I think overall, boring RAW would be better than what we have. My ideal scenario would be that Larian implemented the PHB versions of many (not all) systems instead of what they have now. I think this is the conceptually simplest way of fixing problems that wouldn't be problems if 5E was implemented in the first place.

What problems are we talking about? Because apart from repulsion, practically nothing else is a significant problem that could be fixed by RAW.
In some cases, it could even make the game worse.

RAW 5e is awfully "basic". A clean 5e and especially PHB is quite boring for an RPG game that takes over 100h to complete.
I think Solasta (probably the only 5e game) has shown why the 3.5e is much better suited to gaming.
As a reminder, 5e is designed to be as general as possible to give more freedom to DM.

Last edited by Rhobar121; 26/04/22 12:55 AM.