In my opinion character creation needs:

- an option for scars (preferably face and body)
- two more body presets, e.g. muscular and slim/slender
- a couple more face presets for some races, this is most noticeable with humans but others as well
- the ability to dye our outfits

What I think is also needed:

- some musical instruments are overly large and should be scaled down a bit. The lute and the flute in particular are too large.
- some weapons are oversized and should be made smaller, e.g. the rapier and the longsword.
- most weapons should be worn on our characters' hips instead the back
- equipped shields should be displayed on the back when not in combat

- a generally more "functional" look in armor designs. This mostly effects the +1 and +2 versions