+1 to all this. But in particular to this :
RPG's have had good functional character creation UI's for years that don't have the problems this one does. A rule of thumb is that a) there is no default character and b) you make all your choices from a blank slate in a logical order.
Also, cycling through a list (of hair-styles, make-up, deities, etc) is not a great way to let the user make a choice. Drop-down menus or selection grids (like for eye colours) are better.
