Originally Posted by Sozz
I'm talking specifically about rolling a critical miss when you have advantage on the attack, meaning two ones, which would be...2/20*20? 1/200? or is it 1/400 (Math isn't my strong suit)

I was wondering if maybe the game looks at one dice at a time, then skips advantage when a critical miss is recorded...or I'm just a salty POS, dice muncher

FYI this has never happened during a skill check, I'm only seeing this during combat rolls..."seeing"
I understand that the odds are small. But it does happen. Ive also had the opposite. Rolling 2 20's. Or twice the same number, etc.

Talking from a tabletop perspective. Generally dice are rolled at a far faster rate in bg3 then in actual pnp dnd (at least for my groups) and the player is making ALL the dice rolls. So if hes at the table and his friend rolls a few ones where you all had a good laugh about it. Now the player has ALL of those and it suddenly feels alot more personal.

I think its just confirmation bias tbh. We tend to overlook the positive rolls and only renember the (really) bad ones and when you get all the bad rolls of the party you start to take notice.