Originally Posted by GM4Him
I understood fully.

If you understand, why do you keep going on about powers that don't require rolls.

1. The dialogue choices require a Wisdom roll for something that's literally referred to as an "Illithid" power.
2. I say an Intelligence roll would make more sense.
3. Do you agree that an Intelligence roll would make more sense than a Wisdom roll? Yes or no?

Originally Posted by GM4Him
...and you made an interesting topic no longer enjoyable.


It goes both ways, of course.

But just to point out, me saying that I didn't think you understood was my way of trying to clarify and make sure we were on the same page. Because I didn't understand your reply in context to the topic.

This, however, is just you accusing me of ruining your experience. I don't say that to you with every repeated wall of text that gets posted. I'm not trying to be antagonistic here; I'm simply trying to talk about whether or not the developers mistakenly used Wisdom instead of Intelligence.

Originally Posted by GM4Him
BTW. Natural 1 is only supposed to fail in combat. Isn't that how BG3 plays too? You can't fail a skill check DC 1, right?

No, that's not how it plays in BG3. You can fail a skill check with a DC of 1.