Re-opening the thread after talking with OP to get the thread back on track, so I ask everyone to please stick to the thread's topic, not your injected interpretation of it. For other discussions, start new threads.
The thread meant to be subjective and open ended, a behavioural subject about how the game's designed may either positively reward your player behavior, or punish/disincentivize it compared to how you wish to play the game - And the buck ends there. There is no further nuance, other than "What do you personally want from a game, and does the game sway you towards or away from approaching the game the way *you* want to. It's not about what the game should be, design decisions, or anything like that. Just what you wish for in a game and if BG3 lets you play that way or not.
Keep it on topic please, otherwise it'll be closed again, and further action on individuals may be taken. Respect the topic the OP wishes to discuss and hear what others has to say about.
The topic is generally about the difference between hopes and the reality of BG3.
