Originally Posted by professoryins
why is a dagger a d4 and longsword a d8, every one who crits on the eye will do different damage. you firbolt the eye, roll max damage do 20, they crit the eye with a longsword, 2d8+4 roll max damage do 20.

I think the psychology of it is the big deal.
You are trying to find some logic in system where is none and never was supposed to be any ...

HP, Damage Dices, and Hit Rolls are purely abstract mechanic thigs ... they never was supposed to be anyhow exactly transcripted into roleplay ... you can roleplay them sure, nobody is going to stop you ...
But its still just some abstract number, with no exact meaning. :-/

There is no and never was any hitting the scale, versus hiting the eye ... that is just one of bambzillion possible interpretations. laugh
Aswell as there is no "slight stabing with a Dagger" versus "strong slashing with a Longsword" ... those are simply abstract numbers, so this game is playable in any other way than "you got stabbed ... you died". laugh

Last edited by RagnarokCzD; 22/08/22 06:29 PM.

I still dont understand why cant we change Race for our hirelings. frown
Lets us play Githyanki as racist as they trully are! frown