I would have been neutral about this like, two weeks ago. But I've recently gotten into the scarred lands setting and in it there's an option to create an orc with a starting feat at level one. Having done that and now really scrutinized what feats have to offer for the first time as a result, I definitely choose both. I don't think ASI vs Feat is really an interesting enough choice. Compare that to choosing an archetype at level 3 or whatever, or choosing which spells to learn.
