Let our Tav try to administer potion, but let it be "too late"...
She dies instantly. It's already too late from the moment she started running. The main character trying to shove an antidote down her throat at that point would only make us look silly
Let us look silly then. It's an rpg; we should be given options that allow us to role-play our character in a variety of ways, including looking silly.
Let our Tav to offer her parents last conversation with her.
Impossible to do since Kagha says to bury the child away from sight. So she probably gets dumped somewhere where the sun doesn't shine.
Not impossible while we're still in the conversation. We are literally right there. Make a dialogue option: "Hold up, I can still help her / I'm taking her body with me back to her parents," possibly leading to combat if you insist on it against Kagha's will.
Let our Tav to waste revivify scroll, since her afterlife would be quite fine compared to this existence ...
I don't like when gameplay logic is being used for story logic.
As far as story goes, revive scrolls do not exist within it. They're just gameplay items used solely for the convenience of the player to revive companions. Same as Withers, who has an interesting backstory but in all honesty is just a revive bot.
This is indeed a problem with the game. We shouldn't be given nearly as many revivify scrolls (also, they should only be effective within a minute of death). We should be given 1 True Resurrection Scroll, and then maybe Withers can revive our characters for a *large* fee because, you know, he's a powerful avatar of death.
Or, and this is a novel idea, just let characters die! It's a video game, so if characters die you can a) accept the consequences, b) Use the 1 scroll of resurrection that comes with Gale and suffer the consequences of not having it later, or c) JUST RELOAD. The fact that character death means so little in BG3 takes away a lot of the tension of playing. Who cares if an ally dies during a fight?! As long as you win, everything is totally fine.
That said, if we have a scroll of revivify/resurrection on our person, we should be able to use it on the girl. Such scrolls do exist in the D&D world - it would just make much more sense if they were super valuable and rare.
