I had to check I’d not opened the evil path thread by mistake!
Though I think that this one has got side-tracked into talking about the specific moralit(ies) of that option brings to life nicely the challenges and possible frustrations of a “dynamic” option that took Larian’s weightings of how chaotic or evil (or otherwise) an action was and played it back to us.
EDIT
By the way, thanks for the links @Sozz, the one on 5e alignment is particularly relevant and I don’t remember having read through it before. Some great points made (as well as, perhaps predictably, some bickering round in circles

)!