Its nice picture ...
I like the format a lot ...
But informations there seems little incomplete. :-/
By joining Halsin- you loose not just "all future interaction with Minthara" but also Ragzlin, Gut, and who knows how many other goblins ... Larian makes to gues this especialy hard since all NPCs are named ... i would bet on at least Crusher and Spike tho ... they seem a little more important.
- While its true that we loose all NPCs from goblin camp ... we dont really know if that loss will be permanent if we join Minthara ... after all, she is talking about us being judged by the Absolute at Moonrise Towers ... while if we join Halsin, there is little to none chance that they would forgive that we murdered their boss.
- Also calling Minthara insight "minor" seems hardly fair ... i mean, it seems to me that she is sharing fair deal of intel about cult ... it may be not so interesting as Ketheric Thorm for some listeners, but that doesnt diminish its importance. :-/
By joining Minthara- There is mentioned only romance with Shadowheart ... i admit that i didnt check for few patches, so maybe something changed ... but last time i tryed nobody wanted to spend night with me, but Minthara ...
- Again, calling Halsin's lore "plenty" is strongly subjective for same reasons as abowe ... also, quite a lot of that we can still get from his corpse, and journals ...
- Counting datamined materials ther are other companions that will leave us if we join Minthara ... but that would be spoiler area :-/
Karlach ... and i believe i have read somewhere that Minsc would dislike it too
- It would be certainly fair to mention that while you can fail persuation Minthara and loose her ... its fairly easy check, and if you dont do anything stupid, i believe its difficiulty 1 ... so basicaly unfailable.
- Loosing Halsin as a camp member is good point ... but i believe you also loose Barcus and Volo as your camp companions.
- side note ... i cant help the feeling that counting NPCs in the Grove is little manipulative ...
especialy concidering:
> that there is fair chance that we will never meet any of those druids ever again (they stay) ... maybe, maaaaaaaybe except Kagha, Rath or Nettie ...
> most of them have hardly any interaction, since they only tell us their single sentence and we cant even react on it ...
> and (and this is important part) we can loose them EVEN if we side with halsin ... if Kagha finish her ritual ... wich is completely different questline ...
> same obviously goes for Tieflings aswell ... we can loose them, if Kagha finish her ritual ... most of them have hardly anything to say ...
But we will most likely meet at least some of them again ...
But ... depending on our futher actions, we can loose them all again ...
Second picture ...
I must admit i dont quite understand ... what "lore and story" is lost after battle? O_o
All they say to our character is "thank you" ... everything else they tell you prior the battle. O_o
