There is not much reason to storywise play a Rogue, if you allready seen all Rogue specific reactions and dialogue choices with your Warlock, just bcs that one have Criminal background.
It was never about adding ALL specific options as stated in the original post.
Personaly i think that Inspiration "miniquests" are perfect compromise ...
If you think about it, its foten allready there, just hidden ... if you pick right dialogue choice, wich (in Larian eyes, obviously) would your *insert-background-here* would ... you get rewarded with inspiration.
That is basicaly like having that dialogue [*insert-background-here*] ... just hidden.
That's a matter of taste. It's cool that you can enjoy it.
It's a "meh" for me.
I will never be in favor of removing options just to force replay-value.
Me neither ...
Luckily you cant really "remove" something that was not present in the first place ...
So, this is more like matter of adding or not.
I meant : "Refusing to have options in common between certain races and classes for the sake of "replay-value" is not something I find acceptable.
But sure, let's focus on semantic.
Especially when it means "forcing" players to pick either vanilla answers (usually black or white)
snip
What in the hells. You making assumption about how I play is annoying and I find that section of your response to be particularly condescending. Anyway, I'm going to leave it there because dissecting this wouldn't be constructive and I don't like this type of discourse.
I'll just say this : those suggestions were
never about being "The" answer to the lack of dialogue options. Merely to add more substance to Background and, in part (only in part) helping a little bit with the lack of dialogue options.
And no (can't believe I have to state this), I don't have the compulsion to pick special tags (wtf).
Personaly i beleive that "regular" responces should contain all responces that are in this game, all races, all classes ... all at once.
And then Race-specific and Class-specific options should go to same outcome (maybe with slight bonus, or penalisation to rolls, depending on situation) but with more nuanced texts.
Not a bad suggestion.
Currently, the game seems to rely on one stereotype per class.
So, excluding "vanilla" options (to make things easier, I don't believe it would impact that much anyway), they can only be 12 "uniques" stereotypes (the 12 classes from the PHB).
Dont forget there is also 1 per race.
I did not forget. I'm counting this as things that would not count against my point as they would still be more opportunities to have unique RP experience by adding background options in dialogue than not.
