I'm just waiting for anyone to explain how being opposed to an appearance option that isn't present on any NPC, and would be an extended optional character creation choice like the ones already present, isn't just "Stop liking what I don't like".
I don't think they can.
That's a pretty reductive way of dismissing other people's objections to your idea, it's far more nuanced than that.
So where do we draw the line? Do we respect the source material or should players also be allowed to create 6ft tall Dwarves, Half-Orcs with wings or Gnomes with tails? These examples, while extreme, are also 'appearance options' that some might desire.
