Originally Posted by Oboro
1 ) SPELLBOOK / REACTION MENUS VISIBILITY
Just press K and you have the menu that opens. At first it takes a few minutes of adaptation but in the end I am rather satisfied.

Oh yeah there are shortcut for everything but I still think that such menus deserve their own icon on the main interface.
It should be easy to find them imo, shortcut user or not.

Quote
2) OVERWHELMING REACTION MENU
For smite it is normal to ask if we perform the reaction on critical hit, this is one of the main reasons for the paladin on the table because its double the damage and efficiencie of a smite. The solution you propose is interesting and would allow better visibility. Actually the thief dont have reaction on backstab and Uncanny Dodge , thats a shame.

I don't get it. Ask for every hit would also include to ask for critical hit.
I'm not saying they should not ask for critical hit, I'm saying they should not have a specific line dedicated to critical hit.
But I guess that's for players that don't enable to "ask" option... Whatever something has to be done because it's really gonna be a mess in the end, especially if they include (and I really hope they will) all reactions or skills that can be used with reactions (AOO, sneak attack, feather fall, protection,...)

Quote
6) THE HOTBAR IS TOO SMALL
The icon bar is too small and as I said in a previous post, it is not intuitive. Looks like storage within storage. The passing turn is too big. Personally I used the "Custom" bar from the beginning which is sufficient for level 5 but which will soon be overwhelmed with icons. They should add a bar on the right of the screen, above the text as well as increase the main bar by one lin

I totally disagree with your last sentence on this one.
I'd like the bar to be a bit longer because there are a lot of empty space on the bottom left... But I don't want the UI to be even more overloaded with additionnal bars and additionnal full lines.
There are already too many UI elements all over the screen imo. A bit more confort to deal with the messy hotbar is fine but UI elements everywhere is not something I'd like smile

Quote
I agree on a lot of things but we can see that from one player to another we don't have the same concerns. I would like a lot of better faces and customization of our characters. This time you're not talking about objects which are once again...be good, be too complex or convoluted, or totally useless.
I know you talked about shove in another topic so I'm not mentioning it.
Continue as his maximuss we are with you. smile

Thanks for your support ! I wish I could work FOR FREE with Larian to talk with them, suggest things more directly / think about things with the team, clarify tooltips and so on grin

As you said players don't have the same problems and expectations... In exemple, I personnaly don't care AT ALL about faces and characters custom options.
Items may be another thread at some point because I was (in exemple) so much overwhelmed to see AGAIN many new 50% HP items... but let's be honnest : I've lost hope about itemization.

Last edited by Maximuuus; 21/12/22 01:27 PM.

French Speaking Youtube Channel with a lot of BG3 videos : https://www.youtube.com/c/maximuuus