I feel that if Vengeance is included, it would have to be against the person responsible for sticking a tadpole in your head. Selecting from a menu is back to the problems with ranger Favoured Enemy.

My feeling is that Oath of the Crown is top of the list of non-PHB paladin subclasses, because of oathbreaker guy's backstory.

My personal choice would be Mat Mercer's Oath of the Open Sea (unofficial).

Last edited by FrostyFardragon; 21/12/22 11:54 AM.