Originally Posted by RagnarokCzD
Originally Posted by BROttorney
I feel like Tav should be able to give it back somehow.
Funny ...
I feel exactly other way.

In my opinion, Shadowheart should never hold it in her "pod" ...
It should have ben somewhere nearby, where player simply cannot miss it (and if he would, accidentaly or purposefully, it should break out itself and stick to the player as hard as possible, just as it does when we kill her) ... that would give Shadowheart ACTUAL reason to follow us, even (or mainly) if we refuse to have her in our party/camp.

I do think that Tav should be able to choose to try and give it back (but fails because it got stuck) but your following suggestion would be a nice fix!
It wouldn't require the addition of that many more voice lines and animations, at least based on EA content.
But, at this point, I wouldn't be surprised if they grew allergic to thinking about this whole mess 😅