Would most Paladins travel with Vampires or Char worshipers or even a Githyanki? I question the party makeup... too much in setting up neat storylines then lack of choice forces you to take all these emotional baggage characters with you.
While it’s fair to some extent to require our characters to work with others in the same predicament even if they don’t agree on all points of morality, I do agree that the existing choice of companions could be improved to be less of a clash for a lawful good character. Who might also object to travelling with someone who has made a pact with a devil!
But Larian originally said that they were giving us the evil/neutral characters for EA so hopefully we’ll get more choice in the full release. I don’t think we know exactly who additional companions will be except Minsc and Jaheira (who should suit a good character) and we assume Karlach (who seems very angry and bloodthirsty, so may or may not work for a good character depending on where Larian go with her), but fingers crossed Larian have got more options in store for us.
Also - Would not a rouge steal at will if the urge hit them? why does this break your oath.
Sorry, I don’t understand your point here. Not all rogues would steal without compunction, but I’m not sure what this has to do with a paladin’s oath anyway. I’ve only ever seen an oath broken when the paladin themself steals, not when a rogue in the party does. Have you come across somewhere it works differently?
The oath keeping/breaking logic is poor so far, so I can easily believe there are more oddities.
