just random failed your oath?
did it go away as you were talking or after a battle?
i love the idea of just paying money to make the church ok with your crimes... how very Catholic of them

The first time it was because he attacked a goblin who was considered defenseless and neutral.. Understandable.
The second time, we just couldn't figure out what it was that triggered it. His abilities were just all changed after a battle. I believe it was just after the battle with Minthara, but not sure WHY really. Everyone was hostile because we had Halsin atthis point, so there is no option to talk it out. We didnt save scum either, so at that point we were like 45 minutes in at that point. So we went to long rest at camp to pay it, he accepted the payment, didn't give the oath back lol