Personaly i wouldnt be against either ...
In game where it would serve some purpose. :-/
Say ... IF BG-3 would have much more restrictive resting system, then yeah, it makes sense to give every class some resource to work with ... Casters can loose their spellslots, Shooters can run out of amunition, and Meele weapon can break ... all good i would say.
But what would be the purpose here?
No matter where you are, no matter what is happening (except for combat) ... you can allways simply teleport to nearest vendor and buy/repair whatever you want.
So, what exactly it would bring, or improve?
Nothing, thats what.
You would simply buy 5000 arrows, and never remembered them ever again.
