Hey,
I was currently playing an oath of the ancients paladin. So far I had resolved most things peaceful. (Killing only in the crypt, in the tollhouse and some gnolls) When entering the destroyed village for the first time, I stopped the ambush with a successful intimidation roll. Then I went to the windmill. I had Wyll as companion, so the boss is now dead, the rest ran away.
Then I was playing around with Hamarhraft (deals damage around the location where you land when jumping), injured and subsequently killed one of the goblins in the destroyed village. When he died I lost my oath and got the oathbreaker invitation.
Now I'm confused. As a good aligned paladin, am I supposed to kill goblins? Or help them? Or just ignore them and let them do whatever they like? Or do I really have to make my decisions based on the personality of each individual goblin?