Just saw it, it's really very good. The humor was solid and Hugh, Rodrigues and Pine carried it of course. I have some minor quibbles about …
why a Bard would use his lute as a weapon and not cast spells and what kind of Undead Sofina was supposed to be - also how did Forge fail to find Simon but Edgin found him in one scene?
There were way too many scenes that started by ignoring "how did we get to this location with this going on", but if you ignore that stuff it's great fun. Easily the best D&D movie ever made - not that that is saying much.
