I voted for Insight Park, too, for the same reasons.
I think the Harbormaster should be questioned soon. Specifically about anchors. Daggers can be hidden anywhere, but anchors?
Originally Posted by Lyelle
As for the dagger we've found: I wonder why a murderer would leave the weapon behind. Maybe they had been disturbed.
Are we sure it is a murder weapon? It could have been used for flaying only. The dragonborn was killed elsewhere, with a blow to the head.
Originally Posted by Lyelle
What Selwyn told us made me suspicious: "Then a strange man with a top hat approached me and he began whisperin' awful words in my ear, promisin' to fulfill my heart's most hidden desires. I never would have wished that death on my own worst enemy.” To me, this sounds as if the man with the top hat had cast a spell on Selwyn, and maybe Selwyn had involuntarily killed the butcher.
It is very suspicious. Especially because of what is left out. It is a very long jump from whispering words in an ear to death. Which death Selwyn was talking about? Tav apparently forgot to ask him about that.
Originally Posted by Lyelle
I also think it was the magically disguised top hat man who gave us the letter, not the real Magpie.
That could be, but the person that gave the letter did have the same way of speaking as the real Magpie. I took that to be a hint.
