If we are going strictly the law and goodness scale, Larian is making it clear that the Tiefling is our Chaotic/Good origin charecter. That doesn’t mean there can’t be two, but I agree with Wormerine. Wyll story needs to unfold more, but he can be convinced to torture someone for his personal gain. He doesn’t enjoy, but will do what he needs to do. I don’t see a truly good character so readily doing such things. He’s not evil because he doesn’t enjoy it or isn’t impartial to the act. It bothers him but he does it anyway.
Wyll doesn’t give me the old fashion “free spirit” vibes I grew accustomed to as CN alignments either.
CN leaning good “free spirit” CN leaning evil Wyll?
Again, I see your point, but I'd like to remind you that being good or evil doesn't mean you can NEVER act in the opposite way, just that you really don't like it. Are you going to say Asterion can't be evil because he's willing to help an entire camp full of refugees? Or helps the Mycanoid colony take back their home after being killed by the dwarves? No, he's evil but does some good things, just like, I feel, Wyll does some evil things but is generally good.
As for word of God from Larion, I mean, like I said, alignment means different things to different people, I just call 'em as I see 'em. This is how I'd rate them if they were NPCs in my DnD campaign and someone asked me what their alignments were.
