Huh - this thread made me realize that I haven't played any "new" games since Witcher 3 (and even that only for a short period of time - the opening cutscene kind of poisoned my well). So I'm playing old stand-by classics -Fallout 4, Skyrim, and a smatter of even older games like Civ5, Mount & Blade Warband and Master of Orion 2. If I get the MMO itch, I'll hop into City of Heroes Homecoming or Lord of the Rings Online.
To be honest, the way I feel about the few new games I've bothered to snoop around kind of matches the way I feel about newer movies and series - lots of showing off concepts or characters or fancy new visuals, but not a lot of substance or replayability. But, then, I realize I'm well into the curmudgeon phase of my life.
