I was won over by Karlach on Friday, after being dubious based on the encounter in early access. She was unexpectedly a complete sweetheart and, as we saw in the PFH, definitely romanceable.
I do think balancing romance options to make it “fair” on some grounds is nigh on impossible given it’s so subjective which characters are going to resonate with people and interests differ. Best not to make it a competition and just say what we’d like to see.
(BTW if it
is a competition I will appeal to folk to recognise that at least we’re not in an Anomen vs Jaheira/Viconia/Aerie situation

)