I find it endlessly interesting how regarding Shadowheart in particuar there are two schools - she's a Shar worshipper and so she's evil no matter how nice she is, or she's nice so her being a Shar worshipper doesn't count. I'm personally inclined to think that the trickery domain cleric who worships the goddess of loss and deception may be decieving us, and honestly the kidnapped selunite theory has never felt good to me. It feels like kind of a lame idea personally.
Shame about no Jaheira romance but I figured that'd be the case. We still have plenty of great women to romance.