I don't play evil characters. I find it hard to even make "morally gray" choices, though it's easier if I've already planned out a redemption arc for my character. I like to do good and feel good and spread happiness.

Same.
And OP - I'm also a I'm a save scumming lover good vs evil stories. I'm waiting on a dark urge playthrough until others report that it's possible to run it as a good character. Right now it looks like you don't get a wisdom check to avoid killing small animals - that needs to change before I'll play it.
Anyway - for goodness! *throws flowers around the room and starts dancing*