Originally Posted by Edvin Black
Originally Posted by The Red Queen
I really don't see what an actor's real appearance has to do with them providing a voiceover. Why do you think that's important?

It wasn't just about the voice, it was about whether I would believe this person if she claimed to be barbarian warrior.

Archer? I could believe that.
Rogue? I do not have a problem with it.
Barbarian? Definitely not.

For the same reason, I don't believe that Karlach is a barbarian.
Unsuitable face and inappropriate voice.

But I guess I shouldn't be too hard on Larian.

Karlach was not part of EA and her class and final appearance were only recently revealed.
My guess is that if they had more time, they would have probably fixed her up, as well as Wyll.
It's a shame because Karlach had potential.
Wyll is a Tiefling now, though I haven't seen the new face. I also haven't heard much from Karlach.

I'm more concerned about the scene people said sounded "fake". Some people have a voice you wouldn't match to their face, but that's no excuse for bad voice acting.

I'd also like to bring up the point that the voice may not match on purpose: Karlach would have never chosen this path in life if it were up to her. Conveying this will have influenced the choice of voice actor.