Sure, I think that everyone has their own preferences. I mean, Halsin scars look cool to me. And the same happens with Karlach. I do like more the version with scars. I don't know if Larian made a pool or just follow the feedback that complained about "non-feminine" (not to the MAGA guys liking XD) if there weren't more people vocally praising the scarred version. Maybe they thought this one would be more popular. Who knows?
Well, at least she is still muscled. XD
