I agree. I like how they did it in BG2. There was *one* way, and you could do it *once*. Fall again, or already done that quest? You're now a crappy fighter for the rest of the game.
In BG1 you could slaughter everyone in the Friendly Arm Inn, getting a villainous reputation in the process, walk across the courtyard to the church and donate enough money to be a hero again.
Money for redemption is a BG tradition.
